Reviewing and evaluating other articles
A task sheet for
students to work through several times and hopefully then
internalise.
Name of
article______________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________
Evaluation criteria
|
Notes
|
| What type of article is it? |
Content:
|
| What is the main issue/problem being discussed? |
Content:
|
Skim read – what could your
dissertation gain by including this article?
|
Content:
|
What is the article’s
contribution to knowledge?
|
Content:
|
How can this information be
integrated into your review?
|
Content:
|
Compare and contrast to similar
articles – for or against/ or an extension of the literature?
|
Content:
|
Are there recommendations for
further research?
|
Content:
|
| Where is the article placed in your field? Famous author? |
Evaluation:
|
| Is the article well written, interesting and easy to read? |
Evaluation:
|
Is there a clear research question
– can it be tested?
|
Evaluation
of Hypothesis:
|
What methods are used to carry out
research
|
Evaluation
of the Research Design:
|
Is the design appropriate for
testing the stated hypothesis?
|
Evaluation
of the Research Design:
|
What are the limitations of the
design/research methods?
|
Evaluation
of the Research Design:
|
Are there aspects of the design
that could be applied to your work?
|
Evaluation of the Research Design:
|
Are the results well displayed and
clear?
|
Evaluation
of Data Presentation:
|
Are the results in keeping with
the design?
|
Evaluation
of the Research Results:
|
Are the implications of the study
clear?
|
Evaluation
of the Research Results:
|
Have the results been
appropriately discussed?
|
Evaluation
of further calls for research:
|
No comments:
Post a Comment